ADHD, Communication Differences and Workplace Conflict: What Employers Can Learn from a Recent NHS Tribunal

An employee raises concern after concern. Relationships with colleagues get strained. Emails get longer and sharper. Managers feel challenged, and the employee feels nobody is listening. Then a diagnosis of ADHD arrives partway through, and HR has to work out what is a workplace dispute, what is a disability issue, and what is both.

A 2026 employment tribunal, Millar v NHS England, dealt with exactly that kind of situation. The claimant lost, and every one of her disability claims failed. But the judgment is still worth reading for any People team, because it shows how a long running conflict looks to a tribunal and where the employer came close to getting it wrong.

What happened in Millar v NHS England

Ms Millar was a senior finance manager at NHS England who later worked as a chief of staff on secondment. After the secondment ended she was placed in redeployment during a restructure, and over the following two years she raised six grievances. The tribunal accepted that she was disabled for part of that period because of depression, anxiety, ADHD and panic disorder. Her ADHD diagnosis came in February 2024, after an occupational health report in September 2023 had flagged it as a possibility.

She brought claims for failure to make reasonable adjustments, discrimination arising from disability and victimisation. One of her central arguments was that she had been treated badly for being “forthright and questioning”, and that this way of communicating arose from her ADHD.

The tribunal dismissed the claims. It accepted the diagnosis and accepted that ADHD traits such as impulsivity can affect how someone communicates. What it was not persuaded of was that the critical content of her emails arose from ADHD, rather than from strongly held views about a dispute that had been running for a long time. It also found the employer had not known about her disability before the occupational health report arrived.

Lesson 1: ADHD does not explain every conflict, and it cannot be ignored either

The presence of ADHD does not mean every disagreement, grievance or difficult relationship is linked to disability. The tribunal was clear about that. It looked at each piece of behaviour and asked whether it actually arose from the impairment.

That cuts both ways. A tribunal will also ask whether the employer looked at the question at all. In this case the employer was helped by the fact that it had no knowledge of the disability for much of the period. Plenty of employers will not be in that position, especially now that many more adults are being diagnosed. Our guide to ADHD in the workplace covers the traits most likely to show up at work.

The useful habit for People teams is to stay curious in both directions. Do not dismiss neurodivergence as irrelevant, and do not reach for it as the default explanation for everything.

Lesson 2: Communication differences turn into employee relations cases fast

Communication runs through the whole judgment. One colleague described the claimant as cynical and dismissive; she saw herself as raising legitimate concerns. A five page email criticising a programme and HR became part of the evidence.

Many neurodivergent people are described at some point as too direct, too detailed or too challenging. Sometimes that reflects a real difference in communication style. Sometimes it is a mismatch with unwritten workplace expectations about tone. Usually it gets treated as a conduct or relationship problem long before anyone thinks about neurodiversity.

A manager may read repeated questions as resistance to a decision already made. The employee may believe they are asking for clarity or flagging a risk nobody else has spotted. Once both sides settle into their version, conflict escalates quickly. We look at more of these patterns in how neurodiversity shows up at work.

Lesson 3: Managers need confidence more than clinical knowledge

Many managers feel they need to become ADHD experts before they can support anyone. They do not. They need the confidence to talk about support early, to ask about barriers, and to tell the difference between a capability issue, a conduct issue and a communication difference.

By the time formal grievances and appeals are running, positions are fixed and relationships are hard to repair. Six grievances in under two years is a sign that something stopped working a long time before the tribunal.

Lesson 4: Grievance handling still matters when you win

The tribunal found NHS England had handled parts of the grievance process poorly, partly because of the restructure, and noted that the employer had apologised. That did not make the reasonable adjustments claim succeed, but it is not a comfortable finding for any employer to read about itself.

A slow, disorganised grievance process makes conflict worse for anyone. For an employee with ADHD or anxiety, unclear timelines and long silences can be especially hard going. Clear written updates, named contacts and realistic deadlines cost very little. The camera-on tribunal case from the same year shows what happens when a simple adjustment is left unresolved for over a year.

Lesson 5: Act early

Situations like this build slowly, through misunderstandings, frustration and concerns nobody resolved. By the time a claim is lodged, the underlying problem has usually been there for months or years.

Manager training, regular conversations about support needs and a workplace needs assessment when someone discloses can all surface problems while they are still small. And it is worth knowing that the legal bar for disability is lower than many employers assume, as the Stedman v Haven Leisure appeal showed.

What HR and People teams should take from this case

NHS England won, but nobody would hold up this dispute as a model. The lesson is less about the legal result and more about how to stop a working relationship sliding to the point where a tribunal is the only place left to settle it. Look at the real workplace impact of someone’s neurodivergence, give managers the confidence to have early conversations, and treat communication differences as something to understand before you treat them as conduct.

How Enna can help

We help HR teams and managers handle exactly these situations before they harden into grievances. Our neuroinclusive communication workshop looks at the gap between how something is meant and how it lands, and neuroinclusive management conversations gives managers the language for difficult conversations about performance, conduct and support.

Where an employee has disclosed ADHD or another condition, a needs assessment or workplace coaching can reset a relationship that has started to go wrong. To talk through a live situation, book a call with us.

← Back to Blog